Map frame


View MTB Maps in a larger map

Friday, June 21, 2013

Fi'zi:k saddle review

Fi'zi:k saddles (pronounced "physique" according to the dealer at the Southeast Bike Expo),have a wide variety of styles, materials and shapes, all of which gives each model unique characteristics. I am 6'1", 210, and according to their chart, I am between a bull and scorpion. I am trying this saddle out on my steel Jamis Dragon Race 29er hardtail.  So, here goes....
Aliante vs, bull


Aliante vs, bull, channel cut
Antares vs, scorpion
 
This one has a v shape in the back which slightly curved up and a channel relief grove down the middle. This saddle immediately felt good when I sat on it. It was a much better feel than my old one, even when it was new. I rode 34 miles at bull mountain, mostly on gravel roads do I was able to spend time using the saddle for sitting. I felt I had more room to move fore and aft which is nice to adjust for long climbing. I find myself staying in the saddle longer on long ascents and did not get uncomfortable towards the end. And my favorite part was that my back did not feel like I rode 34 miles, more like 17.


Antares vs, scorpion model
Designed much different from the bull- flatter and stiffer. I wouldn't say it is flat, but the edges are more pronounced. For this test ride, it was not nearly as rigorous and I did not go nearly as far. I didn't have to, I immediately did not like how it felt when I sat on it, but I still gave it a chance with a 5 mile ride. (Pay attention to your first reaction when trying something out, I've found out this with shoes).  I did not like the stiffness and I did not feel that I had enough surface area to change positions on the saddle. Onto the next one...


Aliante vs, bull no channel
Aliante vs,bull no channel
Same design, flexibility and curve going up at the back but no channel cut down the middle. I did not seem to notice, but if you were to wear shorts with minimal padding, it would be evident. There is not much more that I can say about this one that I haven't already said about the first one.
 
Summary
After all that, I went with the first one, the Aliante Versus Bull with the channel.  I have been riding that saddle for almost a month now and I have not been disappointed. The only drawback the the little siderails on the back that are there for protection. I was riding at Jake Mountain and I had to bail on a tight turn and laid the bike down.  The little rail acted like a dredge in the Intracoastal Waterway and scraped up all the dirt and weeds in its path. I pulled out what I could, but there still was some material wedged in there.  I took out the three screws holding it on and cleaned it out.  Otherwise, it has been a great saddle for me.

Go to your local bike shop and see what they have available for a demo.  If the shop is worth a hoot, they'll have a bunch of saddles to let you try- otherwise go elsewhere. The shop at Reality Bikes in Cumming, GA has many to try adn the folks there are very helpful.

No comments:

Post a Comment